Fixed vs Floating Spreads: Which is Better for High-Volatility Trading?

Fixed vs Floating Spreads

Knowing the intricacies of forex spreads can be life-changing, especially in the context of high volatility. The spread is the true difference between the buying and selling price of a financial instrument. It is an important consideration in trading costs and can fundamentally reduce the profitability of the market trade, especially for active traders and traders utilizing volatile assets. In the above, there are two types of spreads: fixed spreads and floating spreads. The differences between fixed spread vs. floating spread can drastically change your trading in volatile markets.

Understanding Fixed vs Floating Spreads

Spreads are the most key concepts in the trading industry, since the time between buying and selling prices of a financial instrument can also be referred to as a spread. If you are interested in a forex trading career alongside the best forex brokers, determining whether to choose a fixed or floating spread is important, primarily if the market is volatile.

What are Fixed Spreads?

A fixed spread provides traders with a certain level of assurance in a market that is inherently unpredictable. A fixed spread would remain constant irrespective of the variation in market conditions. It also provides a predictable cost structure, which allows traders to plan their trading strategies in a lucrative manner. Transaction costs that are continuously fluctuating do not introduce any additional complications.

Fixed spreads can also potentially result in higher overall costs compared to floating spreads during low market volatility.

Advantages of Fixed Spreads

There are a number of advantages to using fixed spreads including:

  • Mitigates uncertainty by allowing for advance planning, providing better pricing transparency and predictability. 
  • You are offered reliable spreads during extremely volatile market conditions. 
  • Preferred by beginner traders, simply because they are easier to understand. 
  • Reduced cost for trading. 
  • Scalping traders are able to execute regularly without issues. 
  • The chance of slippage is greatly decreased.

Disadvantages of Fixed Spreads 

The disadvantages of fixed spreads are:

  • Overall, costs are comparatively more expensive.
  • Brokers with fixed spreads may account for market volatility by purposely spreading them wider.
  • More chances to miss out on possible market opportunities.
  • Less attractive pricing under ideal trading scenarios.
  • The quality of fixed spreads relies on brokers.
  • Reduced flexibility in low-volatility market conditions.

What are Floating Spreads?

During instances of market volatility and lower trading volume, the spread between buying and selling can shrink. On the other hand, when the market becomes volatile due to increased trading volume and various price fluctuations, this spread widens. In regular market conditions, costs are typically elevated by scarcity and competition; however, this phenomenon is analogous. A floating spread is comparable to dynamic pricing used in numerous marketplaces.

Advantages of Floating Spreads

Moving on, the advantages of floating spreads are as follows:

  • Induce reduced costs under stable market conditions.
  • Dynamic pricing facilitates traders and improves market efficiency by manifesting accurate pricing.
  • Provides access to wider liquidity pools, assisting in large trades.
  • Reduced spreads during periods of high liquidity.
  • At favorable market conditions, it is possible for traders to step in or out at quite conducive prices.

Disadvantages of Floating Spreads

Some disadvantages of floating spreads to consider are:

  • Significantly greater prices in volatile markets
  • Greater changes for slippage,
  • Reduced transparency,
  • Unpredictable trading costs,
  • Complexities in monitoring market conditions and adapting tactics accordingly.

Fixed vs Floating Spreads for High Volatility Trading

When volatility is high, the choice of spreads has a substantial impact on trading outcomes. Below are each spread’s unique advantages:

Fixed Spreads Floating Spreads
Predictability: Offer precise calculations. Unpredictability: May widen significantly during periods of strong volatility.
Cost Stability: Stable amidst market volatility. Increased Costs: Incur higher trading costs in volatile markets.
Wider Spreads: Wider range Tighter Spreads: Lower value of spreads.
Limited Flexibility: Less volatile to fluctuating market conditions. Market Responsive: Responsive to real-time conditions.
Cost Analysis: Offers predictability and stability, but might result in higher final overall expenses. Cost Analysis: Cost-effective during stable market periods, but carries significant risks in volatile markets.
Risk Management:

1. Predictability finds favor in volatile markets.
2. Risk management is possible.

Risk Management:

1. Inherently unpredictable.
2. No risk management.

Trading Strategies:

1. Long-Term Traders: Unable to erode potential profits, which permits risk management, ideal for long-term traders.

2. Strategies Sensitive to Price Volatility: Traders can adopt various strategies that absorb sudden price movements based on technical indicators or specific chart patterns. Fixed spreads suit traders at sudden spread-widening periods during high volatility.

Trading Strategies:

1. Scalpers: Scalpers are people interested in executing huge trades within short durations. They aim to maximize profit from small movements, favoring floating spreads during low fluctuations periods.

2. High-Frequency Traders: These traders utilize algorithm-based strategies to execute huge trades at high speeds. They prioritize minimal transaction costs, ideally executed during stable market conditions.

How Spread Types Affect Profitability in Volatile Markets?

Traders benefit from a predictable trading environment, as the cost per trade is guaranteed, irrespective of market fluctuations. This makes the practice of trading appealing to all, as they are able to execute large orders.

Profitability can erode during periods of heightened market activities due to brokers temporarily practicing spread widening.

In contrast, a floating spread adjusts dynamically to market conditions. It can be highly advantageous for traders during high liquidity periods as they may see narrower spreads which may improve their profit potential. However, the inherent risk of the spread expanding significantly is a risk to overall trading performance during times of extreme market volatility.

In conclusion, whether traders prefer a fixed or floating spread will be a function of their trading style, risk appetite and market prediction. Understanding the market clearly is important especially since spread valuations can be extremely volatile and variable making it difficult to manage trading costs.

Conclusion

On a concluding note, one can say that both fixed and floating spreads offer traders a unique set of advantages and disadvantages, respectively, when it comes to the field of high-volatility trading. On one side is the fixed spread that provides traders predictability and stability, making them appealing to no-risk-taking traders.

Conversely, we have a floating spread, which potentially provides lessens costs in less volatile markets, and the ability to adjust to an increase in votality.

In summary, an individual trader’s style, risk tolerance limit, and the environment surrounding the forex market influence their ultimate decision. This information regarding spreads should be a guideline for individuals to perform thorough research in order to assess their styles and preferences to ensure that they are happy with their end decisions.

Maxwell Mutuma
Written by Maxwell Mutuma

Maxwell is a crypto-economic analyst and Blockchain enthusiast, passionate about helping people understand the potential of decentralized technology. I write extensively on topics such as blockchain, cryptocurrency, tokens, and more for many publications. My goal is to spread knowledge about this revolutionary technology and its implications for economic freedom and social good.